Sucheta Dalal :Buy Gold Sell Goldman Sachs
Sucheta Dalal

Click here for FREE MEMBERSHIP to Moneylife Foundation which entitles you to:
• Access to information on investment issues

• Invitations to attend free workshops on financial literacy
• Grievance redressal

 

MoneyLife
You are here: Home » What's New » Buy Gold Sell Goldman Sachs
                       Previous           Next

Buy Gold Sell Goldman Sachs  

June 19, 2006

That is what The Daily Reckoning says on Monday, June 19,2006 - a respected e-letter.

 

At the end of another week, we reiterate our simple investment formula for your benefit, dear reader, but this time, with a new twist: Buy gold! Sell Goldman!

 

Goldman Sachs stock slumped again on Tuesday, although the company had just announced record profits. Goldman is top dog in the "dog and pony" show. But its latest profit report establishes not only a new record for Goldman, but also a record for the whole breed. Net income doubled to $2.31 billion for the second quarter. Based on results for the first half of the year that makes Goldman the most profitable firm in the history of the financial industry.

 

And yet, its stock fell.

 

We are keeping an eye on Goldman these days, because we think it will tell us something: something about the economy, and something about the times we live in. Every dog has his day. Goldman has had a month of them. We wonder: what kind of world is it that Goldman would be on top of?

 

It is one that rewards money mongers. Previous American economies rewarded people who drilled for oil, built bridges, or made mattresses. This one gives its blessings, its honors, and its profits to people who deal in money itself. Goldman deals in money like a Vegas card dealer. Its shuffling is so smooth and so sure that the White House has invited its top shuffler to Washington, hoping he'd bring some of that financial razzamatazz along with him.

 

Yesterday, we tried to get to the bottom of the Goldman mystique.

 

Laboring as always to better serve our dear readers, we happened to travel to Germany, where we ran into an old friend who is a professional investor and a heavy user of hedge-fund products. We put our conundrum to him.

 

"Here's a question," we began. "Trading is supposed to be a zero-sum game, right? Well, how is it possible that a company like Goldman – with thousands of traders - can make 75% of its revenues from trading? You'd think their lucky trades would be balanced out by their unlucky trades. They can't all be lucky. And they can't all be geniuses. As Buffett says, there aren't that many geniuses around.

 

"Or to put it another way, here's a company making billions, mostly by trading. Who's on the other side of these trades? Who's losing? Where does the money come from? How is it possible for so many traders to have a result that is so far beyond equilibrium...it seems to defy gravity."

 

"Yes, it is a curiosity," said our friend. "You're right about hedge funds. I mean, what you wrote about them. The average person will do no better in hedge funds than in mutual funds. In fact, he'll do worse, because of the fee structure. As you noticed, if he gets lucky, the manager will stand right there beside him, with his hand out, when the payoff comes. If he's unlucky, and the fund loses its bets, he'll be in line alone. The manager won't share the losses.

 

"'The average man doesn't wish to be told that it is a bull or a bear market,' wrote the legendary Jesse Livermore once. 'What he desires is to be told specifically which particular stock to buy or sell. He wants to get something for nothing. He does not wish to work. He doesn't even wish to have to think.'

 

"You're right, too," continued our friend, "that there aren't 8,000 geniuses running hedge funds. The average return will not be very good. But you're wrong to tell investors to stay away from them. I'm invested in several hedge funds. In every case, the manager has figured out some special little sweet spot in the market. Usually, it's some little thing that most people don't know about. For example, one fund I'm in is run by a guy who just makes a point of catching the 'earnings surprises' before Value Line.

 

"Value Line figured out that you can do well by buying companies whose earnings are better than forecast. After the earnings come out, it takes Wall Street a while before it adjusts its view of the company to the higher earnings. But it also takes a while for Value Line to get the news and update its rates. This manager uses the same simple idea; he just moves faster. And he consistently beats the market.

 

"There are anomalies out there. Good hedge fund managers find them and exploit them. And good investors find the hedge funds that do that and negotiate their own fees to a reasonable level. But the average investor has no idea. He picks up a hedge fund like he buys a bottle of wine - because someone told him it was good. And then, he pays fees that are so high it is almost impossible for him to make any money."

 

"But what about Goldman?" we asked.

 

"Goldman is said to be the largest hedge fund in the world, but in fact, it is, the largest collection of hedge funds in the world. It has hundreds of them. It has a great reputation...and it has its hands in more deep institutional pockets than anyone. So, it get so much money under management that it makes a fortune, even when its results are not spectacular. And in a sense, it is also the bank. It is not just playing in the casino; it is the casino. Goldman is trading so much money for so many people, it makes money no matter which way the markets go."

 

The question for investors is this: Is the casino getting bigger, or is business falling off? Investors answered yesterday: they sold Goldman. For once, we think they were right.

 

http://www.dailyreckoning.co.uk/article/160620061.html

       


-- Sucheta Dalal



 



Recent Comments